Thermal protection is an important part of transformer protection because excessive temperature can damage winding insulation, deteriorate transformer oil and reduce the service life of a transformer.
Large power transformers are generally provided with temperature-monitoring devices to detect abnormal temperature conditions. These devices can give an alarm, start cooling fans or operate the circuit breaker when the temperature exceeds predetermined limits.
The main devices discussed in this topic are:
- Oil Temperature Indicator (OTI).
- Hot Spot Thermometer or Winding Temperature Indicator (WTI).
- Thermocouples and Resistance Temperature Detectors (RTDs).
The following article explains their construction, working principles, applications and differences in simple language.
📚 Table of Contents
- Introduction
- Thermal Overheating Protection System
- Oil Temperature Indicator (OTI)
- Typical OTI Settings and Loading Conditions
- Hot Spot Thermometer (Winding Temperature Device)
- Construction of Hot Spot Thermometer
- Working Principle of Hot Spot Thermometer
- Why Is WTI More Accurate Than OTI for Winding Temperature?
- Short-Time Heavy Overload and Long-Time Light Overload
- Difference Between OTI and WTI
- Role of Thermocouples and RTDs
- Comparison of Temperature Protection Devices
- Frequently Asked Questions
1. Introduction
A power transformer operates continuously under different load conditions. During operation, heat is produced in its windings, core and other internal components.
The main sources of heat generation in a transformer are:
- Copper losses: These losses occur in the primary and secondary windings due to the resistance of the conductors. They increase with load current.
- Iron losses: These losses occur in the transformer core due to hysteresis and eddy currents.
- Additional losses: Leakage flux and other stray effects also produce heat in transformer components.
The heat generated inside the transformer increases the temperature of the winding insulation and transformer oil.
If the temperature exceeds the permissible limit for a long period, the insulation may deteriorate. This reduces the expected service life of the transformer and may eventually lead to winding failure.
Therefore, large transformers are provided with thermal overheating protection to monitor their temperature and take suitable action whenever the temperature becomes excessive.
2. Thermal Overheating Protection System
Thermal overheating protection monitors the temperature of transformer oil and windings.
The temperature-sensing devices are installed at suitable locations. Their outputs are connected to temperature indicators, control circuits, alarm circuits and tripping circuits.
Some transformers use thermocouples or Resistance Temperature Detectors (RTDs) near the windings. These sensors can be connected to suitable measuring and control circuits, including bridge circuits, to detect temperature changes.
When the measured temperature increases beyond a preset value, the corresponding control action takes place.
Typical Temperature Settings
The following temperature settings are mentioned in the reference material:
| Operation | Typical Temperature Setting |
|---|---|
| Switch ON cooling fans | 60°C |
| Alarm | 95°C |
| Trip | 120°C |
How Does the Protection System Work?
The operation can be understood in three stages.
Stage 1: Cooling Fan Operation
When the transformer temperature rises to approximately 60°C, the temperature control circuit switches ON the cooling fans.
The fans increase heat removal from the transformer radiators and help maintain the oil temperature within the desired range.
Stage 2: Alarm Operation
If the temperature continues to increase and reaches approximately 95°C, the alarm contact operates.
An alarm is provided to alert the operator that the transformer temperature has become abnormally high.
The operator can then check the transformer loading, cooling equipment and other operating conditions.
Stage 3: Circuit Breaker Tripping
If the temperature continues to rise and reaches approximately 120°C, the trip contact operates.
The trip signal is sent to the associated circuit breaker, which disconnects the transformer from the electrical system.
This prevents continued operation under an excessively high-temperature condition.
3. Oil Temperature Indicator (OTI)
3.1 What Is an Oil Temperature Indicator?
An Oil Temperature Indicator (OTI) is a temperature-measuring device installed on an oil-filled transformer to measure the temperature of the transformer oil.
It is commonly provided on oil-filled transformers and is generally installed at a location where it can monitor the hot oil circulating inside the transformer.
During transformer operation, the oil absorbs heat from the core and windings. The heated oil moves towards the upper portion of the tank, while relatively cooler oil moves towards the lower portion.
Therefore, the oil temperature indicator is positioned so that it can monitor the hot oil, which is important for assessing the thermal condition of the transformer.
An OTI may also be provided with adjustable alarm and cooling control contacts.
3.2 Construction and Working Principle of OTI
An oil temperature indicator generally consists of:
- Temperature-sensing bulb or probe.
- Temperature-responsive measuring mechanism.
- Dial and pointer.
- Capillary connection, where applicable.
- Adjustable electrical contacts for alarm and cooling control.
The temperature-sensing element is placed in a suitable pocket in the transformer tank.
As the transformer oil temperature increases, the sensing element responds to the temperature change. The measuring mechanism moves the pointer on the dial to indicate the oil temperature.
If the device is provided with electrical contacts, these contacts can be adjusted to operate at predetermined temperatures.
3.3 Functions of an Oil Temperature Indicator
The main functions of an OTI are:
1. Indication of Oil Temperature
It continuously indicates the temperature of the transformer oil.
2. Cooling Fan Control
The OTI can be used to start cooling fans automatically when the oil temperature reaches the preset value.
This helps remove additional heat from the transformer.
3. High-Temperature Alarm
If the oil temperature exceeds the specified alarm setting, an alarm contact operates.
This provides an early warning to the operator.
4. High-Temperature Trip
Where provided in the protection scheme, a separate high-temperature contact can initiate circuit breaker tripping.
3.4 Limitations of Oil Temperature Indicator
Although the OTI is useful for monitoring transformer oil temperature, it cannot be considered a complete fault-detecting device.
The main reason is that transformer oil has a much longer thermal time constant than the transformer windings.
Let us understand this in simple language.
When transformer loading increases, the current flowing through the windings also increases. As a result, copper losses increase and the winding temperature may rise relatively quickly.
However, the transformer oil takes more time to absorb this additional heat and show the corresponding temperature rise.
Therefore, the OTI may not immediately indicate the actual temperature condition of the winding.
For example:
- During a sudden increase in load, winding temperature may rise quickly, while oil temperature increases more slowly.
- During a sudden reduction in load, winding temperature may decrease relatively quickly, while oil temperature may remain high for some time.
Because of this difference in thermal response, the OTI may sometimes give a conservative indication or may not immediately reflect the actual winding thermal condition.
4. Typical OTI Settings and Loading Conditions
The reference material describes a typical arrangement in which the oil temperature indicator operates cooling fans and alarm contacts at different temperatures.
The settings mentioned in the reference are:
| Function | Typical Temperature |
|---|---|
| Cooling fan operation | 60°C |
| Temperature alarm | 90°C |
The reference also provides an example for a transformer operating at an ambient temperature of 30°C.
Under this typical design:
- Cooling fans may start at approximately 90% of rated load.
- The alarm may operate at approximately 130% of rated load.
These percentages are illustrative values from the reference, not fixed values for all transformers.
Why Do Loading Percentages Change with Ambient Temperature?
Ambient temperature means the temperature of the surrounding air.
For example, a transformer operating in an environment of 40°C will have less temperature margin available for cooling than the same transformer operating at 20°C.
Therefore:
- At an ambient temperature above 30°C, the permissible loading percentage for the same temperature settings may be lower.
- At an ambient temperature below 30°C, the permissible loading percentage may be higher.
The actual loading capability depends on the transformer design, cooling system, insulation temperature limits and manufacturer's loading recommendations.
Adjustment of OTI Contacts
The reference material states that the switches are generally capable of readjustment over a range of approximately ±10°C.
This adjustment allows the operator or commissioning engineer to compensate for certain operating and installation conditions.
However, the final settings should always be selected according to the manufacturer's instructions and approved protection philosophy.
5. Hot Spot Thermometer (Winding Temperature Device)
5.1 What Is a Hot Spot Thermometer?
A Hot Spot Thermometer, also known as a Winding Temperature Indicator (WTI), is used to estimate the temperature of the hottest portion of a transformer winding.
The hottest portion of a transformer winding is called the winding hot spot.
The winding hot spot is particularly important because the insulation at this location experiences the highest thermal stress.
If the winding hot spot temperature becomes excessive, the insulation may deteriorate rapidly.
The hot spot thermometer therefore provides a more useful indication of the winding's thermal condition than an ordinary oil temperature indicator.
5.2 Why Is a Hot Spot Thermometer Required?
Consider a transformer operating under heavy load.
As the load current increases, the winding copper losses increase.
The copper loss is given by:
Where:
- Pcu = Copper loss in watts.
- I = Winding current in amperes.
- R = Winding resistance in ohms.
This equation shows that copper loss increases with the square of current.
For example, if the winding current becomes twice its original value, the copper loss becomes:
Therefore, the copper loss becomes four times the original value, assuming the resistance remains unchanged.
The increased copper loss produces additional heat in the winding.
The winding temperature may therefore increase faster than the oil temperature.
An ordinary OTI may not immediately indicate this rapid increase in winding temperature.
To obtain a better indication of winding thermal conditions, a hot spot thermometer is used.
6. Construction of Hot Spot Thermometer
The reference material describes a hot spot thermometer arrangement consisting of the following main components:
- Thermometer bulb.
- Temperature-sensing pocket near the winding.
- Heating element.
- Current transformer (CT) secondary connection.
- Temperature-indicating mechanism.
Thermometer Bulb
The thermometer bulb is placed inside a suitable pocket near the transformer winding.
The bulb is surrounded by hot circulating transformer oil.
Therefore, it responds to the temperature of the oil near the winding.
Heating Element
A small heating element is provided near the thermometer bulb.
This heating element is connected across the secondary of a current transformer.
The current transformer supplies a current proportional to the transformer load current.
As the load current increases, the heating element produces more heat.
This additional heat raises the temperature of the thermometer bulb.
How Does the Heating Element Work?
The heating element produces heat according to the principle of electrical heating.
The heating effect is related to:
Where:
- P = Heat-producing electrical power.
- I = Current through the heating element.
- R = Resistance of the heating element.
As the load current increases, the CT secondary current also increases proportionally, provided the CT and its circuit operate normally.
Consequently, the heating element produces more heat.
Thus, the thermometer bulb receives heat from two sources:
- Heat from the surrounding transformer oil.
- Additional heat from the CT-operated heating element.
This arrangement helps the device estimate the winding hot spot temperature.
7. Working Principle of Hot Spot Thermometer
Let us understand the operation step by step.
Step 1: Normal Transformer Loading
When the transformer operates at normal load, the transformer oil has a particular temperature.
The thermometer bulb senses the temperature of the hot circulating oil.
At the same time, the CT secondary supplies current to the heating element.
The heating element produces heat corresponding to the load current.
The combined thermal effect determines the thermometer reading.
Step 2: Increase in Transformer Load
When the transformer load increases, the winding current also increases.
As a result:
- Copper losses increase.
- The CT secondary current increases.
- The heating element produces more heat.
- The temperature of the thermometer bulb increases.
Therefore, the indicated temperature rises to represent the increased thermal condition of the winding.
Step 3: High Winding Temperature
If the estimated winding temperature reaches the preset alarm value, the associated alarm contact operates.
The operator receives an indication of excessive winding temperature.
If the temperature continues to rise and reaches the trip setting, the trip contact can initiate circuit breaker tripping, where such protection is provided.
Step 4: Reduction in Transformer Load
When the transformer load decreases, the CT secondary current also decreases.
Consequently, the heating element produces less heat.
The temperature indication gradually responds to the reduced thermal condition.
8. Why Is Hot Spot Thermometer More Accurate Than OTI for Winding Temperature?
The hot spot thermometer is more closely related to the actual thermal condition of the transformer winding than an ordinary oil temperature indicator.
The reason is that it considers both:
- The temperature of the oil near the winding.
- The additional heating effect corresponding to transformer load current.
An ordinary OTI mainly indicates the temperature of the transformer oil.
It does not directly account for the additional temperature rise caused by winding copper losses.
The hot spot thermometer uses a CT-operated heating element to simulate this additional winding temperature rise.
Therefore, it provides a better estimate of winding temperature.
Matching with the Transformer Heating Curve
The reference material explains that the hot spot thermometer is matched with the heating curve of the transformer winding.
This means that the heating element and thermometer arrangement are adjusted so that the indicated temperature follows the expected thermal behaviour of the winding.
The artificial heating produced by the heating element is designed to represent the additional temperature rise of the winding above the surrounding oil temperature.
However, the accuracy of this indication depends on proper matching and calibration.
9. Short-Time Heavy Overload and Long-Time Light Overload
An important observation from the reference material is that a short-time heavy overload may produce a higher reading on the hot spot thermometer than a long-time light overload.
Let us understand the reason.
The hot spot thermometer has a thermal response that depends on both the surrounding oil temperature and the heat generated by its CT-operated heating element.
During a Short-Time Heavy Overload
- The load current increases significantly.
- The CT secondary current increases.
- The heating element produces substantially more heat.
- The thermometer indication may rise relatively quickly.
During a Long-Time Light Overload
- The load current is comparatively lower.
- The heating element produces less additional heat.
- The temperature indication develops according to the longer-duration thermal condition.
Therefore, the short-time heavy overload may register a higher temperature on the dial than the long-time light overload.
10. Difference Between OTI and WTI
Both Oil Temperature Indicator (OTI) and Winding Temperature Indicator (WTI) are used for monitoring transformer temperature.
However, they measure or estimate different thermal conditions.
| Particular | Oil Temperature Indicator (OTI) | Winding Temperature Indicator (WTI) |
|---|---|---|
| Full form | Oil Temperature Indicator | Winding Temperature Indicator |
| Main purpose | Indicates transformer oil temperature | Estimates winding hot spot temperature |
| Sensing arrangement | Senses hot transformer oil | Uses oil temperature and CT-operated heating element |
| CT connection | Not required for basic oil temperature measurement | CT secondary is used for the heating element in the described arrangement |
| Winding temperature estimation | Does not directly estimate the winding hot spot | Provides an estimate of winding hot spot temperature |
| Response to load changes | Relatively slow because oil has a longer thermal time constant | Also has a thermal response, but includes a load-current-dependent heating effect |
| Main application | Oil temperature monitoring and cooling control | Winding thermal monitoring and protection |
| Control functions | Fan control, alarm and other configured contacts | Fan control, alarm and trip functions where provided |
11. Role of Thermocouples and RTDs in Transformer Temperature Protection
Large transformers may also use thermocouples or Resistance Temperature Detectors (RTDs) to monitor temperature at selected locations.
These sensors convert temperature into an electrical signal that can be measured by a suitable instrument or control system.
Thermocouple
A thermocouple consists of two different metal conductors joined together.
When the measuring junction and reference junction are at different temperatures, a small voltage is produced.
This voltage is related to the temperature difference and can be measured by suitable equipment.
Resistance Temperature Detector (RTD)
An RTD is a temperature sensor whose electrical resistance changes with temperature.
For example, a platinum RTD such as Pt100 has a nominal resistance of 100 ohms at 0°C.
As its temperature increases, its resistance increases in a predictable manner.
The measuring circuit detects this resistance change and calculates the corresponding temperature.
Bridge Circuit
In some temperature-measuring arrangements, the sensor is connected to a bridge circuit.
When the temperature changes, the sensor resistance changes, causing the bridge circuit to become unbalanced.
The resulting electrical signal can be used by the measuring or control system to indicate temperature and operate alarm or trip functions.
The exact sensor type, measuring circuit and protection arrangement depend on the transformer design.
12. Comparison of Temperature Protection Devices
The following table summarises the main differences between the temperature-monitoring devices discussed in this article.
| Device | What It Measures or Estimates | Main Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| OTI | Temperature of transformer oil | Oil temperature indication and cooling control |
| WTI | Estimated winding hot spot temperature | Winding thermal monitoring and protection |
| Thermocouple | Temperature at the sensor location | Temperature measurement |
| RTD | Temperature at the sensor location | Accurate electrical temperature measurement |
14. Frequently Asked Questions
Q1. What is thermal overheating protection of a transformer?
Thermal overheating protection is a protection arrangement that monitors transformer oil and winding temperatures and provides suitable control actions when the temperature becomes excessive.
Q2. What is OTI in a transformer?
OTI stands for Oil Temperature Indicator. It is used to measure and indicate the temperature of transformer oil.
Q3. What is WTI in a transformer?
WTI stands for Winding Temperature Indicator. It estimates the temperature of the hottest portion of the transformer winding.
Q4. Why is OTI not sufficient for winding temperature protection?
Transformer oil has a longer thermal time constant than the windings. Therefore, oil temperature changes more slowly than winding temperature when transformer loading changes.
As a result, OTI may not immediately indicate the actual winding thermal condition.
Q5. Why is a CT connected to the WTI?
The CT secondary supplies current to a small heating element in the WTI.
The heating element produces heat according to transformer load current and helps simulate the additional temperature rise of the winding due to copper losses.
Q6. What happens when transformer temperature becomes excessive?
Depending on the temperature settings and protection scheme:
- Cooling fans may start.
- A high-temperature alarm may operate.
- The circuit breaker may trip.
Q7. What is the difference between OTI and WTI?
OTI indicates transformer oil temperature, whereas WTI estimates the winding hot spot temperature using the oil temperature and an additional load-current-dependent heating effect in the described arrangement.

